Monday, September 17

Maritime Monday 76

Welcome to this Weeks edition of Maritime Monday.

You can find Maritime Monday 26 here. (Published 11 September 2006)

You can find last week's edition here.

This Weeks Photos:
This weeks photos come out of the accident report covered by Mr. Dennis Bryant of Holland & Knight:

Haight's Maritime Items has:

UK – report on shipping container collapse - The UK Marine Accident Investigation Branch (MAIB) issued the report of its investigation of the collapse of shipping containers on a container ship in the Baltic Sea on 26 February 2007. The investigation revealed what appears to be a systemic problem with the rapid loading of containers, allowing minimal time for the ship’s officers to determine whether the loading is being done in accordance with the load plan and to calculate the effect of the loading on ship stability, among other factors. The report recommends development of a best practice safety code and other industry-wide changes. Report No. 21/2007 (9/13/07). - Dennis Bryant Holland & Knight homepage (Used with Permission)

The photos:





This is an interesting report for anyone who does stowage planning. It will become even more relevant as the number of large vessels increases, increasing the chances of similar incidents since average stack heights will increase.

Here is a picture I took while working in the container depot in Helsinki as a container damage inspector. You can see some of the IBC 30 foot bulk containers in the background. In the foreground are a couple of containers on the inspection stand:

Here is a picture from the report of the CSC plate of one of the bulk containers:

The ACEP sticker means that the container is part of an Accepted Container Examination Program.

The owner of a container is responsible for maintaining that container in a safe condition and must arrange for a container to be examined in accordance with certain procedures and at prescribed intervals for the purpose of determining whether the container has any defect that could place any person in danger.

For leased containers, by virtue of lease agreements the owner or lessor normally transfers these responsibilities to the lessee.

As part of minimum requirement for depot's, most shipping companies, instruct empty container depots to examine every container in accordance with the owners/lessors requirements that enters the empty yard for compliance with the owners/lessors respective CSC scheme. If within CSC, then the container must have a minimum prescribed time in accordance with the respective maintenance schemes provided under CSC (i.e.90 days time left before next due plate update). In the case of ACEP, then it must be sound for the full 30 months (on equipment 2 ½ years or older). For any unit not conforming to owner/lessors CSC/ACEP scheme requirements, the depot is normally requested to quote to effect repairs to bring the container up to the owners/lessors standard or to advise the container owner or agent of the containers non-CSC conformingcondition. - Shipping Australia

Of course every shipping line has different standards.

Finally, here is a photo of one of the worst crushed containers I have run across. It was dropped from a container crane. As you can see, it was full of glass:


'Broken Glass'

This Weeks Items:
Eagle Speak has "More secure containers?". Also, be sure to check out his weekly series "Sunday Ship History: The Inchon Invasion, September 1950"

Maritime Accident Casebook has the special report "The Case Of The Killer Catch". Once again the instrument of death is the lifeboat which takes the lives of two seafarers during a safety drill. The report lists a number of good points about how needlessly complicated the gear is for attaching and releasing the falls from the lifeboat. Personally I tend to prefer the old open boats with the single lever marked "DANGER LEVER DROPS BOAT". With the open boat, it is easy to see that you are in the water and permits easy access to the falls. Also the hooks can be secured before attaching the falls. Surely this system was not perfect, but at least you were not trapped inside, and provided that the 'manropes' were maintained, you at least had something to hold onto in case the lifeboat dropped out from under you.

Here is the lifeboat setup from the M/V GALVESTON BAY, which was photo of the week here. Go read the explanation of why the lifeboat was so high up on the house. One thing I did not mention at the time, was that this photo was taken while weight testing the falls. This was done by filling the boat's bilge with water. The problem came when the Chief Mate ordered me (the deck cadet) to ride the vessel down to the water with an AB (I had no problem with that) and then release the falls (I had a problem with that). I refused, explaining to the mate that the boat would flip as soon as I did that. I then was chewed out by the mate in front of the Coast Guard inspector (who, by the way, stood there and said nothing). I was finally let off the hook by the Port Engineer who heard all the noise and came to investigate. He then berated the Mate because some other fool Officer on a sister ship did something similar resulting in the death of two while the ship was docked in New Jersey. The Chief Mate wanted to release the falls as it required to be done once every three months and he figured he would save a little time by combining the two tests:

Imagine being in this lifeboat as the ship rolled.

gCaptain has what is apparently bad news to a number of US Merchant Mariners who were a little creative with their work-related meal 'expense' deductions with his post "Mariner Tax Deduction “Kapp-sized” By IRS". (For those who don't know, the ship provides your meals at sea, at no additional cost to you.) The relevant part is that the Government is demanding names of clients back to 2000. That sounds somewhat unfair to me, because I was under the impression that they can't go after you for more than 3 years back as long as you file. Anyway, gCaptain promises to keep on top of the story here.

I was originally going to link to this gCaptain article "Aw Nuts! By The Artful Blogger". To better understand the barrel reference, look here, but only if your not easily offended. (If you are easily offended, you are at the wrong corner of the internet.) Hmm, who knows, maybe the barrel reference will also apply to the other gCaptain post.

Honolulu Advertiser explains the fears of those who inhabit the outer islands that the Hawaii Superferry will ruin their isolation. (Better transportation connections normally do that.)

Superferry has announced that they will restart service between Kaua‘i and O‘ahu starting on September 26 and have posted on their website "the Summary of State Law Consequences" (PDF Document) (which includes Federal charges for interfering with the Coast Guard). The list was released by the State of Hawaii as a warning to protesters who might consider breaking the law, again.

The Economic Times (India) has the latest on the BLUE LADY scrapping battle in "Blue Lady's fate uncertain as activists to challenge SC". Apparently, it was finally approved because the vessel had already been beached. The Oregon Telegraph has the expected reaction from the environmentalists in "Rights and environmental groups condemn Blue Lady ruling". Technically, this should be an internal Indian matter since the owner of the vessel is an Indian Shipbreaker, who planned to profit from recycling the ship. Go here for Flickr photos of Alang Ships.

The Pilot Boat brings in the dead ship/Portuguese ferry ILHA AZUL for repairs.

Shipping Times (UK) has "Scottish Government urged to abolish fishing fleet 'slave labour'" noting a number of severe abuses on EU-Registered fishing vessels.

'Manoeuvre' in Maritime Asia has "Taiwan to Construct Spratly Air Base". There is a small issue in that China has also claimed the islands for themselves as do a number of other countries. Back in school the big NAVTAG simulation involved the Spratley Islands. My watch actually won the event by kamikaze-ing our last jet into the Chinese troopship sent to occupy the islands. The instructor thought it would be amusing to enable the kamikaze option but never thought that it would be the deciding factor in the game.

Tims Times posts a sea story from his first arrival in the US. The story is titled "Divine Intervention"

Robin Storm takes a good look at remotely operated underwater vehicles including how they assisted in the salvage of the M/V BOW MARINER.

Logistics Management has one company's switch from shipping cargo from Air to sea in "Ocean shipping strategies: Risk versus reward". In many cases, shipping by air is not as fast as you would think it is. That is a problem for the air carriers as moving cargo by sea is getting faster.

The Daily Dispatch (South Africa) has a list of accidents off the Eastern Cape Coast of South Africa in "WILD COAST: The ship wrecker".

Sailor Girl (Atlântico Azul - Paixão pelo Mar) invites you to participate in Royal Race Regatta on 5 October, 2007, in Portugal.

MarEx Newsletter has "Flag State Activities Crucial to Promoting Safety at Sea"

DC Examiner has a story on the Baltimore International Seafarer’s Center. Their website is located here.

Titanic International Society’s Web Log has "Coast Guard appoints first woman to command Ice Patrol". That would be US Coast Guard LCDR Gabrielle McGrath.

UN Atlas of the Oceans has Captain Caroline Lallement, the first female Ship Captain in France. (So it claims.) For those who can manage, the French language story can be found here.


French Captain Caroline Lallement

The Boston Globe has the story of one entrant to the upcoming Vendée Globe around the world alone race.

Bosun Bob's Locker has a good example of why it is a bad idea to have nobody awake on watch in a story of the sailboat OUZO being run over by the channel ferry PRIDE OF BILBAO (Wikipedia info here) in ""Reflectors are virtually useless" (Damning report on Ouzo sinking)". The reflector mentioned is the radar reflector carried on many sailboats. So be warned. While they had that, they did not have other, more useful equipment, such as an EPIRB or even lights for their lifejackets. That is a shame since they survived the sinking of their sailboat, only to die in the water. The MAIB Report can be found here. (PDF File.)

Environmental News Network has "Indian Ocean sees smallest tuna catch in 11 years"

SAILORS, MARINERS & WARRIORS LEAGUE has "the claim by and Animal Rights Group Saying that it sank the Whaling Ship WILLASSEN SENIOR in Norway.

Steeljaw Scribe has the firing by Russian President Vladimir Putin of Russia’s Navy Chief, Admiral Vladimir Masorin, possibly for accepting an award from the US Chief of Naval Operations.

National Public Radio has a photo essay and radio presentation "Exploring for Oil in the Arctic's 'Great Frontier'"

Maritime Links Editor's Blog has "Maine Maritime Academy Enrollment at All Time High!" Hmmm, seems like a trend.

Maritime Compass posts about the arrest of the former facilities director of Mystic Seaport, Cindy Snarski, for stealing thousands of dollars of copper wire.

Tugster has the Dutch-Flag, US-based canal boat GOLDEN RE'AL.

The Canadian Press has the head of the Canadian Navy, Vice-Admiral Drew Robertson state that the Navy needs to learn how to fight pirates and terrorists.

With yet another example of why Greenpeace should be thrown out of the International Maritime Organization (IMO), again, and just in time to back up the statements of Canadian Navy Vice-Admiral Robertson, is their post "Pulp freighter blockade in Canada"

How about slacking this line out and dunking this guy? I bet his attitude would change pretty quick:

"Greenpeace activist suspended from mooring lines" - Greenpeace

Where are the fire hoses?


Greenpeace keeps getting away with this because ship's crews are not given the GreenLight to repel them. Here are some ways to protect the ship if you find yourself being attacked by Greenpeace: (Note: Anything you do is your responsibility, although it is Greenpeace that forces you to act.)

- Use fire hoses and fire monitors. Add Foam or soap to make everything slippery. Deliver the soap inside water balloons and then use the hosed to foam it all up.

- Use the anchor wash if there is an attempt to secure themselves to the anchor chain.

- Use paintball guns. For more effect, shoot Pepper balls.

- Have the engineers whip up a couple potato cannons. Instead of potatoes, you can try ice cubes for a shotgun effect.

- Make use of expired flares. Just don't shoot them skyward.

Navy Times has the damage being done to our Navy by the shrinking number of shore duty jobs and reduced chances for advancement. (Hmmm, it has been about 5 months since I submitted by request to resign from the Navy Reserves.)

Read "Cheating death (Lloyds List)" for the amazing story of the survival of the entire staff of the American Bureau of Shipping who escaped from the 91st floor of the first World Trade Tower to be hit. The plane hit right above their floor and nobody escaped from any of the floors above them.

Finally, EU Observer has "EU abandons metric conversion for UK and Ireland".

Fairplay Daily News has:

Fury as Norway scraps tonnage tax - OSLO 10 September – The Norwegian government sent autumn chill through the country’s shipping community by presenting a framework for the taxation of shipping that effectively means cancellation of the tonnage tax system and massive claims for payment of tax credits incurred since 1996 when it was introduced. A new system will be published with the government’s draft budget on 6 October. The Norwegian tonnage tax meant that operating profits were untaxed unless taxable dividends are paid to the shareholders or if assets are moved out of Norway. The government now intends to reclaim these tax credits. The Norwegian Shipowners’ Association (NSA) estimates that the credits amount to between 14 and 21 billion kroner ($3.6Bn). “A claim to pay the so called tax credits will lead to selling ships and newbuilding contracts on wholesale scale and massive exodus of Norwegian shipping to Denmark, Great Britain and Germany,” NSA said in a statement, adding that the equity of many companies will be dramatically reduced, in some cases by half. Taxation of shipping has raised controversy in Norway since 1996, when the tonnage tax was introduced. Ship owners say the system adopted has not offered the same benefits as those in use in many EU countries. Some economists say all business in Norway should be taxed equally to ensure the best use of funds invested. A shipping analyst told Fairplay that listed companies with domiciles abroad, such as Frontline, Golden Ocean or Nordic American, would not be affected at all. Those domiciled in Norway, including many privately owned firms, could be badly affected. “This is tough, but I don’t think the last word has been said yet,” he predicted. - Fairplay Homepage (Used with Permission)

That was just the first act. Then the other shoe dropped:

Tonnage tax: Oslo doubles the pain - OSLO 13 September – Norway’s finance ministry is to double the tax bill for shipping companies already reeling from the double blow of losing the tonnage tax and the demand for back tax. A letter from the Norwegian finance ministry to one shipping company stipulates that market values rather than book values should be used in calculating owners’ tax liability following the abolition of tonnage tax, which can double the bill owners face to NK40Bn ($7.1Bn). Per Saevik, MD of the offshore vessel group Havila, said in an interview webcast on tv2.no that the letter had stipulated that owners’ tax liability should be based on the market value of their fleet and not on the book value as owners had assumed so far. He described the situation as dramatic and said that talks are needed between the owners and the government to address the problem. The very existence of a number of companies would be in jeopardy if an NK40Bn bill was levied on the industry. This, in turn, would have serious consequences for ancillary industries such as shipbuilding and marine equipment manufacturing. The Norwegian marine cluster employs some 90,000 persons, which is about 5% of the workforce in a country of four million. - Fairplay Homepage (Used with Permission)

It seems that Norway is determined to kill off their shipping Industry by burying it in taxes.

Submissions for future editions:
Please submit articles for inclusion in next week' edition using the following submit form at Blog Carnival. You are also welcome to email photos for inclusion in future editions as well as suggest area of coverage.

** Sponsorship **
Send me an email (address in the sidebar) if you would like to sponsor an edition of Maritime Monday. I accept money and gear.

Previous Editions:
Here or click on the label below 'MaritimeMonday'.





.

Thursday, September 13

Congressional Abuse of a General

OK, I was a sucker for listening to the two days of Congressional hearings on Iraq as our 'favorite' Congressmen grandstanded over the need to evacuate our troops out of Iraq A.S.A.P.

First, I am amazed at General Petraeus's seemingly unlimited ability to maintain Self Discipline. Clearly, this has been honed over years of service to our country.

Second, I found it pretty damn amusing that on both days, the Chairmen of the hearings had trouble controlling the spectator/protesters, who interrupted the hearings multiple times. If Congress cannot control their own hearing room, then it is understandable that the US might have a difficult time controlling all of Iraq, especially considering that terrorists in Iraq try to blend into the local population by not dressing in bright pink to make themselves easily identifiable as the misfits in the Congressional hearings did. Why Code Pink has not been banned from hearings entirely is a complete mystery to me.

Now the General has proposed a reduction in troops and the news is suggesting that the President will announce as reduction as well. The General also provided a draft timeline, as illustrated in the following slide he presented to Congress:



General Petraeus suggested a drawdown of troops up until July, 2008 which as it happens is the latest date mentioned in the timeline. However, by that date, the number of troops appear to be reduced by 25% and possibly more than that. Of note is how the mission the troops are performing changes over time. The graph also provide the template for the rest of the withdrawal. It is just missing the dates, which did not sit well with the Democrats at the hearings.

The Democrats, seemed to be working hard to blunt any mention of any sort of progress being made in Iraq. This was done mainly by highlighting previous failures and using the past as reasoning for getting out as well as failure to comply exactly with plans made up months ago. That is a shame since by recognizing the progress that General Petraeus is claiming, they can push for withdrawals based on the progress made and expected. That path however causes problem for those running for President. (see below)

Sunk costs:
Sunk cost has been a major theme in the Democrat's plan to surrender in Iraq. Basically, we were losing, so we need to pull out to be sure that we lose.

This is how Wikipedia explains 'Sunk Cost':

In economics and in business decision-making, sunk costs are costs that have already been incurred and which cannot be recovered to any significant degree. Sunk costs are sometimes contrasted with variable costs, which are the costs that will change due to the proposed course of action. In microeconomic theory, only variable costs are relevant to a decision. Economics proposes that a rational actor does not let sunk costs influence one's decisions, because doing so would not be assessing a decision exclusively on its own merits. - Wikipedia

So whenever you hear a Democrat discussing how we need to get out of Iraq because we have spent too much money there and that we has lost enough lives, that is an example of basing a decision on sunk costs. With that sort of reasoning, we never should have invaded Afghanistan since nothing we could have done would have brought back the lives lost on that day, nor given us back the twin Towers. They were simply sunk costs. Thankfully, President Bush, and the Congress at that time didn't see it that way.

The 2008 Presidential Election:
There is one sticking point about the July, 2008 date that none of the Congressmen mentioned during the hearings, in that the date is right in the middle of the 2008 Election campaign. That is a serious problem for Democrats. First, Bush, and whoever is campaigning on the Republican side, is surely to benefit from any troop withdraws announced in March 2008 to start in July 2008, especially if they are coming home, leaving a relatively peaceful Iraq. That is the other problem for Democrats in that as time goes on, there is less bloody news footage coming out of Iraq.

So there is the need for the Democrats to force a quick pullout from Iraq. If things continue to get better without troops there, they can claim the credit for having the foresight to do the pullout. If things don't get better, or get worse, they can claim that having the troops there would not have made the country any better, but would have resulted in more US lives lost. Even better, they can blame Bush for keeping the troops there for too long, which resulted in the country becoming dependant on our presence.

Then there is the issue of the moveon.org ad. The Democrats running for President only seem to be bothered by how best to not say anything that might upset moveon members. While Moveon has the right to print something like that in the paper, it is something that every member of Congress as well as everyone in the Government should condemn for the poison that it is.

Out of the whole hearing only one question seems to have great importance, that was of gauging Iran's sincerity at discussions in Iraq over the country's security. The answer was simply that they were to there to give the appearance to be helping, but in reality they were not interested at all in actually doing so. Good luck in having any of the Democrats push to hold Iran to account for its recent actions in Iraq, Syria or Lebanon.

What seems to be missing from the Democrat side as the simple fact in the rebuilding of Iraq and its Government, you just can't fill all the positions with just anybody. You need qualified people to do the jobs. A person becomes qualified to be an Iraqi General by working his way up the ranks. As General Petraeus stated, that is the problem as the lower ranks have a severe shortage of personnel due to a lack of qualified people prior to the US invading Iraq. So they are working quickly to get people the needed skills and experience to move up. The same goes for the rest of the Government positions, which were mostly non-functional under Saddam Hussein.

Now we could do this in a half-assed sort of way, but that is not how we are doing it. We are not trying to rebuld the Iraqi Army into a third-world militia. We are turning their forces into a first-rate professional, voluntary military. That is not small act. We are also trying to help the Iraqis build a first-world Government. That too takes time.

Time the Democrats don't want to give them. Because that will interfere with their goal of taking back the White House. That sounds like no plan to win an election.

More:
Grim Milestones - 13 March 2007

Bad Driver in Maryland

This happened a couple of years ago, but the problem of bad drivers certainly has not gone away. This is an example of a person being completely careless as well as having no respect for the people around them.




You would think that there would be a little pride in owning a car. As you can see, this car has temp plates. You would think that they would be a little careful with it, if for no reason other than making sure that you have a car that operates. Had this car have a passenger, my car would have gotten a dent from the huge door opening with no room for it. I was temped to leave one myself but that is not how I do things.


(Yes, there are lots of bad drivers in Maryland)

Wednesday, September 12

Stalin was Deadlier Than Two Nuclear Bombs

It all start with this idiotic comment by Russian President Vladimir Putin denying the criminal past of the Soviet Union and the terror it inflicted on it's own people:

Another teachers' guide getting Kremlin support, meanwhile, recasts key elements of Soviet history. Dictator Josef Stalin is described as "the most successful Soviet leader ever," for building industry and leading the country to victory in World War II. The guide explains his purges and the system of camps for political prisoners as a function of his desire to make the Soviet Union strong.

Mr. Putin himself echoed that view at the meeting with teachers, saying Stalin's "Great Terror" of 1937 -- during which at least 700,000 people were executed -- wasn't as bad as atrocities other nations had perpetrated, such as the U.S. use of the atomic bomb. - WSJ (Alt Link)

Is he kidding? For starters, the 700,000 Stalin executed were his own citizens. The US dropped atomic bombs on the enemy, not on our own people. As for how much damage those two bombs did:

Hiroshima: As a result of the blast an estimated minimum 90,000 people died within two months.[24] Included in this number were about 2,000 Japanese Americans and another 800-1,000 who lived on as hibakusha, a Japanese term meaning, "explosion-affected people". As US citizens, many were attending school before the war and had been unable to leave Japan. It is likely that hundreds of Allied prisoners of war also died. - Wikipedia

By December of 1945, thousands had died from their injuries and a small number from radiation poisoning, bringing the total killed in Hiroshima in 1945 to perhaps 140,000. In the years between 1950 and 1990, it is statistically estimated that hundreds of deaths are attributable to radiation exposure among atomic bomb survivors from both Hiroshima and Nagasaki. - Wikipedia

Nagasaki: According to some estimates, about 70,000 of Nagasaki's 240,000 residents were killed instantly, and up to 60,000 were injured. The radius of total destruction was about 1.6 km (1 mile), followed by fires across the northern portion of the city to 3.2 km (2 miles) south of the bomb. The total number of residents killed may have been as many as 80,000, including the few who died from radiation poisoning in the following months. - Wikipedia

The two US atomic bombs dropped on Japan during World War II killed approximately 220,000 people. That is less than a third of the people that Stalin executed in the 'Great Terror' of 1937 (As opposed to the great terrors of all the other years). That of course was just a fraction of the total number that died under Stalin's rule:

... it appears that a minimum of around 10 million surplus deaths (4 million by repression and 6 million from famine) are attributable to the regime, with a number of recent books suggesting a likely total of around 20 million. Adding 6-8 million famine victims to Erlikman's estimates above, for example, would yield a total of between 15 and 17 million victims. Robert Conquest, meanwhile, has revised his original estimate of up to 30 million victims down to 20 million. Others, however, continue to maintain that their earlier much higher estimates are correct. - Wikipedia

As for Soviet deaths during World War II, a citizen of the Soviet Union was more likely to be killed by his own Government than by the German Military.

Maybe Stalin is considered the "most successful Soviet leader ever" because he managed to kill more than any of the other leaders before or after. Not that the others didn't try:


Putin's comments comparing America's actions during WWII to Stalin's murder rampage are insulting and dangerous.

P.S.
Just to show you how nice the Soviets were, they also dropped nuclear bombs on their own citizens as well.

Decades of Soviet nuclear testing unleashed a plague of birth defects. When the Soviet Union tested its nuclear devices, it chose eastern Kazakhstan, one of its remotest, most desolate areas. But no one bothered to evacuate the people living there.

The testing began in 1949 at a site known as Polygon and continued until 1989. According to the Nuclear Threat Initiative, there were 456 tests, including 116 nuclear bombs tested above ground. The Polygon site officially closed on August 29, 1991 -- 16 years ago this week.

Local officials say there were hundreds of thousands of people, possibly as many as a million, who lived in the region during the nuclear testing. The end of the Cold War might have ended this dark chapter, but thousands are still paying a terrible price. - CNN (Warning, the story is horribly graphic)

Anything bad the US might have done the Soviet Union was many times worse. And no, Russia has not taken ownership of those helping those who continue to suffer today from their atomic bomb blasts.

Remembering the Soviet Union v.1


World War II casualties - Wikipedia

Tuesday, September 11

Life Goes on for Most of US

Today is the anniversary of the September, 11 terrorist attack.

For me, life goes on pretty much like normal. I did not lose any family in the attack. I did not know anyone who died in the attack. The only real connection I had was that I did visit the towers a couple of times. I enjoyed visiting them. They were literally a modern marvel, until some thugs decided to destroy them for no good reason at all. In the process, they murdered thousands of people. They did not care who they murdered. It could have easily been any of us.

Returning from sea. March '93, just after the first WTC attack.

These criminals could have done anything they wanted in Afghanistan, and most Americans would have cared less about what they were up to. But that was not good enough for them. So as far as I am concerned, they can all rot in Gitmo, provided they are not wiped off the planet first. There are six billion people on this planet. These guys are rotten apples and should be treated as such.

Previous 9/11 Posts:
World Trade Center Tribute - 11 September 2006

Glenn J. Winuk - One of Many 9/11 Heros - 11 September 2005

Return of the Free Speech Thieves

This was to be expected. The free speech thieves have returned to disrupt Congressional hearings on Iraq. Look at these clowns...

Capitol Hill police officers remove a protester from the crowd during a joint hearing of the House Armed Services Committee and House Foreign Relations Committee featuring Gen. David Petraeus and US Ambassador to Iraq Ryan Crocker in Washington, DC. What was billed as the most electrifying day of testimony in Congress for many years lurched into farce Monday as Petraeus struggled to be heard and members of the anti-war group Code Pink were dragged kicking from the room.(AFP/Getty Images/Alex Wong) - Yahoo News

A protester holds up a sign before being escorted out by Capitol Hill Police during testimony from the US Commander in Iraq General David Petraeus before a joint hearing of the House Armed Services and Foreign Affairs committees on the state of the war on Capitol Hill in Washington, DC. What was billed as the most electrifying day of testimony in Congress for many years lurched into farce Monday as Petraeus struggled to be heard and members of the anti-war group Code Pink were dragged kicking from the room.(AFP/Tim Sloan) - Yahoo News

U.S. Capitol police remove an anti-war protester from the hearing room as U.S. Army General David Petraeus (not shown) and U.S. Ambassador to Iraq Ryan Crocker testify before the House Armed Services Committee and the House Foreign Affairs Committee on Capitol Hill, September 10, 2007. Demonstrators repeatedly interrupted the hearing and were removed. REUTERS/Jason Reed - Yahoo News
These protesters have the right to protest elsewhere. They also had the right to attend the hearing. They did not have the right to disrupt it. For doing so, it was claimed that they would be arrested and prosecuted to the full extent of the law. Most likely, the harshest penalty they will receive was the rough handling they got as they were escorted out of the room. That is a shame, since there are 300 million of us, and they took seats from others who would not have abused the privilege to attend the meeting.

Let's be clear, disrupting a meeting is not free speech, it is hijacking the meeting for their own purposes, whatever they are. 'Codepink' and all the other protest groups can legally protest outside. However, that does not generate the exposure that they think they deserve so they have to go and interrupt meetings like this one to get some press coverage. This shows complete disrespect for the right of free speech because they are trampling over the free speech of others as well as trampling on the rights of the rest of us to not listen to them. (They also have the right to visit the offices of Congressmen to express their views. Then again, visiting your congressmen does not normally get you into the news.)

How about blogging instead, or perhaps even taking out a full-page ad in the New York Times, like this obscene one by moveon.org:


Of course it helps if you have friends at the paper to extend you a discount. Personally, I think the ad is shameful, however, let them waste their money on BS like this. Let them waste all their money on ads that show their true intentions. Then, let them offer to help Democrats in their election campaigns.

Original Post:
Free Speech Thieves - August 2006

Monday, September 10

Maritime Monday 75

Welcome to this Weeks edition of Maritime Monday.

You can find Maritime Monday 25 here. (Published 3 September 2006)

You can find last week's edition here.

This Weeks Photos:
Just out of the center of Washington, DC, you can find a Memorial to the TITANIC.

The Women's Titanic Memorial is a granite statue in southwest Washington, D.C., that honors the men who died on the RMS Titanic. The thirteen-foot-tall figure is of a partly clad male figure with arms outstretched. The statue was erected by the Women's Titanic Memorial Association. - Wikipedia




This Weeks Items:
First, lets start with a warning from a joint enquiry by gCaptain and Robin Storm: "gCaptain - Robin Storm Joint inquiry - F/V Papa George" (gCaptain link here) alerting readers to a possible malfunction of an EPIRB (For a summary on what an EPIRB is, look here) in an accident that resulted in the loss of two lives. They are looking for information from anyone who has had EPIRB problems or malfunctions.

Eagle Speak has the news "Strait of Malacca: Strait states agree to cooperate"

Also be sure to check out Eagle Speak's weekly series "Sunday Ship History: Silly Song, Strong Message"

Honolulu Advertiser has the court's refusal to block the new Hawaii Superferry vessel ALAKAI from docking on the island of Kauai. As I had predicted, the story notes that protesters are vowing to stop the service if it returns to the island. I comment on the Coast Guard's announcement in preparation for future Superferry sailings in "Coast Guard Threatens Hawaii Superferry Protesters with Serious Fines and Jailtime". Beware the big stick. You don't want to be the guinea pig.

gCaptain has the amazing "Ship Battling Arctic Ice - Photos"

gCaptain also has a contest where you can win an iPhone or iPod Touch. Go find out how to win. (Then go and vote for Maritime Monday, Here!)

State University of New York Maritime College (SUNY Maritime) started this school year with its largest freshmen class, ever. Yet one more example of a healthy Maritime training programs in the US, the only first-world nation that has managed to maintain graduating large-numbers of professional Merchant Marine Officers. (Kind of hard to encourage people to seek a life at sea, working seven days a week, when all their friends are living the 'good life' with jobs limited to under 40 hours of work a week, by law. 35 hours in France. Did I mention that overtime is often mandatory?)

SAILORS, MARINERS & WARRIORS LEAGUE has Sweden's decision to mothball their largest vessel, the HMS CARLSKRONA, a minesweeper. At least, it was a minesweeper. The problem is a lack of qualified officers. (See my comments above.)

HMS CARLSKRONA - Sweden's largest paperweight

The Monitor has "Queen of Oak Bay TSB Report Released". Go read his post to learn which nut on the ship is the most important.

The Queen of Oak Bay, a BC ferry crushes dozens of small pleasure crafts while running aground in Horseshoe Bay, British Columbia, Canada. - Wikipedia


Shipping Times (UK) has the story of the unpaid crew on the cargo vessel MEUGANG 1 who were forced to work under horrible conditions.

The Yankee Sailor comes back from leave to learn that he will be reassigned to a destroyer as XO.

The MarEx Newsletter has South Korea's Unification Minister's crazy suggestion that South Korea should consider redrawing its sea border with North Korea as they have an issue with the current line. (Why do I think that the North has other contentions that they would like to address.)

The Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe (OSCE) has a conference in Helsinki, Finland on 10 and 11 September to address maritime and inland waterways cooperation.

Statistics Norway has "Less cargo over Norwegian ports"


Occupational Medicine has a short report covering 866 cases of Maritime Health Emergencies on US-Flag ships that "made contact with US emergency medicine physicians for advice". (Only 2% of which were psychological. That's amazing.)

Bitter End has "DHS to Spend $10m in Seattle to Screen Small Boats" for radiation. This on the heels of an alert looking for these two suspicious guys who have been riding Seattle Ferries and have yet to be located, as far as we all know.


An Unofficial Coast Guard Blog has a Pentagon video program covering "The Coast Guard and illegal immigrants crossing to the USA".

Sea Fever has the coming global ban of TBT which is commonly used for anti-fouling paint in parts of the world. It has fallen out of favor in the west years ago due to it being 'toxic paint'.

The Independent (South Africa) has the abandoned and sinking bulk carrier AMUL off Port St. Johns.

Robin Storm covers a report that has the conclusion that "Stronger Hurricanes Mean Whopper Waves".

EU Observer has "EU stands firm on Gdansk shipyards" in demanding that the production capacity of the yards be reduced.

Never Sea Land has a photo of the newest, greatest 'Most Powerful Engine'. (Haven't we been down this road already? It is a biggie.)

Tims Times has the childish misuse of ship radios and even provides a response to the often-heard derogatory hail 'filipino monkey' (either said or whistled) that I have not heard of before.

Not to be outdone by foreigners, The Stupid Shall Be Punished has the great read describing childish behavior in the Engine room "Urban Legends, Nuke Style". Be sure to read the comments as well. Yes, childish behavior, while in charge of nuclear reactors. Gotta love it. (Just imagine what they do on Russian Nukes.)

Speaking of Russian nuclear submarines, Molten Eagle is looking for an answer into what is the red object issued to Russian sub crew in the photo he has posted and is asking international submariners to provide input if they know.

The Arkansas Inland Maritime Museum at North Little Rock has "In Memoriam - USS Grayling (SS-209) - Sunk 09 September 1943"

Mr. Boat Blog has news of the North-West passage being free of ice for the first time in recorded history.

Pilot Online has good news for the restoration of the Nuclear ship NS SAVANNAH in that a contract has finally been awarded. (A year late.) Wikipedia has a summary of the vessel's history here.


NS SAVANNAH - in 1962

The Local (Sweden) has Sweden's increasing popularity as a port of call for the most exclusive Megayachts. Too bad that Swedes have to move out of the country to be able to afford a megayacht.

Helsingin Sanomat has problems for Argentina in finding a replacement for their heaviliy damaged icebreaker ALMIRANTE IRIZAR due to a fire. The problem is, they need the icebreaker for their summer to use in Antarctica, but the possible replacements are needed in the north at the same time for winter service.

Ocra Marine Services has "Private Equity Firm To Invest $1 Billion In Norwegian Cruise Lines "

Life of a Sea Wife has "Comfort of the Sealife"

The Pilot Boat discusses ships turned into museums in his post titled "Better than to be scrapped..."

Kiwi at Sea experiences a trip as a "VIP Ferry passenger" on an English Channel P&O Ferry.

Freaque Waves has the newest 'extreme sport' of surfing waves created by calving glaciers. And yes, there is video.

Tugster has the historic tug CORNELL "built at Jakobson’s Shipyard in Oyster Bay in 1950." The shipyard is gone, turned into a maritime center. It is on that location that the Lightship NANTUCKET is currently located. (As featured as Photo of the Week in Maritime Monday 65)

Hindustan Times notes that Indian Officials have replied 'not yet' to the US offer to donate the landing ship USS NASHVILLE (LPD 13) to their Navy. They first want to evaluate the USS TRENTON of the same class which they have just taken control of as the INS JALASHVA, expected in India today, 10 September.

Free republic readers comment on India's non-payment for aircraft 'upgraded' by Russia, as the aircraft failed to detect a submarine as it should, insisting that the aircraft problems be fixed first. (Imagine that, accountability.)

Haight's Maritime Items has:

Fire on MORRO CASTLE – 1934 - On the evening of September 7, 1934, as the passenger ship MORRO CASTLE was returning to New York City following a vacation cruise to Havana, the master was found dead in his cabin from an apparent heart attack. At about 0300 on September 8, fire was discovered in the passengers’ Writing Room. The fire spread quickly through the ship, which contained fancy wood paneling and expensive cloth curtains. The acting master steamed for the nearest land – Asbury Park, New Jersey. The fire was faster than the ship; 137 passengers and crew died by the time the ship was beached. The casualty led to numerous fire-safety improvements in future passenger ships. - Dennis Bryant Holland & Knight homepage (Used with Permission)

Fairplay Daily News has:

New ID scheme for Indonesian crew - JAKARTA 3 September – Indonesia has approved nine centres for verification of Seafarers’ Identity Documents, ready for its imminent ratification of the ILO Seafarers’ Identity Documents Convention (2003). Seafarer organisations are hoping for an early ratification that would pave the way for Indonesian seafarers to be allowed into US ports. Chairman of Indonesian Seafarers’ Union Hanafi Rustandi told Fairplay that ratification would help remove Indonesia – a predominantly Islamic country – from the US blacklist. The US has given Indonesia $400,000 to set up centres to process seafarers’ ID, though the cost is likely to exceed $1M. The centres will be established at the ports of Tanjung Priok, Belawan, Tanjung Emas, Tanjung Perak, Balikpapan, Makassar, Bitung and Sorong. Indonesia’s ratification will pave the way for nearly 15,000 Indonesian seafarers to man merchant ships bound for the US, Rustandi said. - Fairplay Homepage (Used with Permission)

Submissions for future editions:
Please submit articles for inclusion in next week' edition using the following submit form at Blog Carnival. You are also welcome to email photos for inclusion in future editions as well as suggest area of coverage.

** Sponsorship **
Send me an email (address in the sidebar) if you would like to sponsor an edition of Maritime Monday. I accept money and gear.

Previous Editions:
Here or click on the label below 'MaritimeMonday'.


.

Thursday, September 6

No Bailout for Homeowners in Trouble

Who says the US has no Social Welfare System?

As most of us know, with a couple of exceptions for flippers in denial, there is a huge problem in real estate with homeowners unable to pay their mortgage payments.

As a result there have been increasing calls for the Government to bail out these 'unfortunate' struggling homeowners who are now in a real mess. A mess partly created by those who are in trouble now.

Many homebuyers took out adjustable-rate mortgages to take advantage of low interest payments for the first two or three years. When their rates reset higher after the initial period, those buyers couldn't handle the bigger bills. - Forbes

Stupid. Simply stupid. Especially considering that fixed rate mortgages were at their lowest levels in a long time.

People have forgotten a couple basic facts:

- Your house is not an ATM machine.
- You don't buy something that you can't afford.
- A house is not an investment you trade like a stock.
Now take a look at who will benefit by a bailout:

A presidential bailout of homeowners who can't pay their mortgages would likely be a boon for the companies making the mortgages. Originators like Countrywide Financial (nyse: CFC), Accredited Home Lenders (nasdaq: LEND), and H&R Block (nyse: HRB), which has a subprime lending subsidiary, have been crunched by rising defaults. It would also benefit companies like Thornburg Mortgage (nyse: TMA) that hold mortgages for investment. - Forbes

These are the very firms that thought it was perfectly fine to approve loans to people they knew could not afford them.

The basic fact is that many of the people in trouble now knew that their loans would reset in a couple years time. They just figured that they would sell their homes to some bigger fool. Unfortunately for them, everyone had the same idea. That would not have been a problem, except for the fact that none of these people realized that they were the bigger fools.

As we will all eventually learn, this problem is too big to bailout, partly because even with an interest rate of 0%, many homeowners now in trouble would still be unable to afford their homes, because they lied about their income.

Right now we’re seeing 30-40 calls a day. And 85 percent of these families we can’t help, simply because the gap of what they can afford and should have been able to afford is so huge,’ said Ester Cadavid, chief development officer of Los Angeles Neighborhood Housing Services. ‘They bought too much house. Even if we refinance them into a fixed-rate (mortgage), the payment is still too much. - Housing Bubble Blog

Had they been truthful from the start, they never would have been able to obtain the mortgages they are now complaining about. Lets not forget that many committed a crime when they lied to obtain a mortgage.

Another issue in all of this is that a good number of homeowners in trouble own more than one home. Of course they lied on multiple loan applications in order to pull off this feat. Many of these homes were purchased with no money down, so the homeowner loses almost nothing compared to the damage their foreclosure will do to the holder of the loan. (Oddly enough, homeowners in trouble who put down large down payments actually get hurt the most, since they actually have an investment in the property.) Paying only interest on your house loan is not much different that renting, other than a renter can call management when he has a problem with something, or better yet, move away. (Yes, their credit rating is ruined, but that is because it is merely recording the poor quality of their credit-worthiness.)

Lets say there is a bailout. Do you help those who lied? Do you help those who have multiple houses? What about those who used their homes as ATM machines (either through a home equity line of credit or refinanced in order to cash out) and spent whatever liquidity they might have had on vacations and expensive cars and other toys? What about those who used their house cash to pay off existing credit card debt only to max out their cards again? What about those who bid up the prices of houses that they could not afford in the first place? What about all of those properties that were purchased as investments? How about those who paid the lowest payment in a negative ARM loan from day done? What about those who NEVER made a mortgage payment?

What about those people who were just-plain-stupid?

The Orlando Sentinel reports from Florida. “The champagne-popping days are over for Natalie and David Luongo, who banked enough money flipping a South Florida condo three years ago to stage a $100,000 wedding. Should they walk away from the $117,000 deposit they plunked down on another investment condo in the ritzy Miami-Dade enclave of Bal Harbour? Or should they close on the one-bedroom unit, which is similar to others now on the market for less than the $585,000 they agreed to pay?”

“‘It’s painful and scary,’ Natalie Luongo said. ‘We saw the frenzy, and we bought in. Now we’re paying the consequences.’” - As highlighted on The Housing Bubble Blog

Sure mixed in all of this is a minority who is in trouble and probably deserve help. However, there is no saying that they will take advantage of any assistance made available wisely. Really, if you were responsible when purchasing a house, you would have done your best to obtain a fixed-rate loan (which were at historic lows) that way you would have known what your mortgage payment would be every month for the life of the loan and could plan accordingly. That would leave only loss of income or family emergencies to risk making those payments. People in trouble took the riskiest loans they could. That type of behavior does not warrant assistance.

There is another problem here. This housing market is headed down no matter how much money the Government attempts to throw at it. It has grown just too big to the point that most people cannot afford houses at the current asking prices. There is another simple fact in that many of the people in trouble own multiple properties. Renters like myself will be hard-pressed to purchase one house, let alone multiple properties. This is an issue of plain simple supply and demand. And the rest of us are not going to buy at today's inflated prices because we can all find places to rent that cost less than what would be the monthly interest due for buying these houses.

There currently exists ways to end troubled home-ownership. Home owners can either let the house be foreclosed on, they can file for bankruptcy or attempt to negotiate with their lender, or whoever they are sending their payments to, some sort of reduced payment plan. With the value of these mortgages being slashed drastically on the resale market, the newest holders of the loans have leeway to reduce the payback amount to prevent the home 'owner' from defaulting. Then, there is the possibility of attempting a short-sale.

For a whole blog's-worth of examples of why homeowners in trouble should not be bailed out, go read the Bubble Markets Inventory Tracking blog.

For many examples of abusive lending practices, go read Housing Bubble Casualty.com, who comments as follows about a housing market bailout:

Creative financing, no risk assessment, and loose credit created this monster…risk assessment, tighter credit, and traditional financing (fixed rate loans paying principal) will rein it back in. If the mortgage industry and the secondary market didn’t discard risk assessment the past 5-6 years to get these ‘high risk’ people loans, they would NOT be defaulting today. - Housing Bubble Casualty.com

So, What to do to help the Economy?

If the Government is so interested in pouring money into the market to help the economy, then they should give the money to me and the millions of other American who acted responsibly over the last couple of years, while others raced headfirst into this mess.

We have our accounts in order, or are working in the right direction. We are the one's spending within our means. So how about increasing our means? We will make the best use of the money and unlike if the Government were to give it to the idiots, we won't be needing more money in a couple of years (or months). For me, I can go out and finally buy a new car (Mine has 190,000 miles on it.) Hell, I could even consider getting a second one for the wife. We can go out and buy a nice large flat screen TV and a house full of furniture to go around it. Give me enough money, and I'll even consider buying one of these houses that is currently held by a distressed buyer. One thing is for sure, we'll limit ourselves to a house we can afford. If the Government wants to help, then that is how they should go about doing it.

I think that as the housing market melts down nationwide, the calls will become louder not for a bailout, but for placing those responsible in jail. The appraisers, the predatory lenders and the flippers should not be allowed to get away with any criminal activity they might have done. There has not been much enforcement in the past, but I expect that will change as news gets out over the losses these poor-quality loans will generate.

This is surely just the beginning of the story.

P.S. -There should be no change in the Taxation of Forgiven (Short Sale) Income:

This is a bad idea:

Quick example: you buy 450k home. You have trouble making payments. You refi or negotiate with lender and the property is now worth 350k. That 100k that the lender ‘forgave’ is currently taxable as income. But under the proposed change, that would be a free ‘100k’. I know that taxes are a pain (see FairTax.org) but why should somebody get a ‘free’ 100k or whatever the amount is, and not have to pay ANYTHING on it. Again, it is another ‘reward’ for making bad financial decisions. - Housing Bubble Casualty

And a little clarification by a commenter on the site:

Another pointed out, “The vast majority FBs will never have to pay any extra taxes even without changing the rules (therefore, this rule change will be worthless). ‘There’s a very important exception to the debt-relief-equals-taxable-income rule. Although lenders must send 1099-C forms reporting taxable income whenever cancelled debt is $600 or more, the tax bill itself is forgiven if the homeowner is bankrupt or insolvent.’ Link here.” - Housing Bubble Blog

There needs to be a price to pay for irresponsible behavior. Take gambling at Las Vegas. Sometimes you win, sometimes you lose. Most people will walk away as losers. While the Government gives you a little leeway on your losses, they are not going to give you your money back. It should be no different for housing. (The Government already does not tax interest paid on a mortgage.)

Wednesday, September 5

Being Less Poor: iPhone Price Reduced $200

Well if you really wanted an iPhone but just could not stomach parting with $600 to buy one, you have just be rewarded for not giving into the impulse as the price for the 8 gig iPhone has just been reduced by $200 to $399.

However, the fees for the mobile phone service has not been lowered and that is going to cost you around $3,000 over two years (or even more depending on how fast governments add taxes to your phone bill). If you want the iPhone for the other features and can care less for the phone itself, then you're in luck, because the new "iPod Touch" is an iPhone without the phone, and without the service contract. Oddly enough, it will cost as much as the iPhone above, for now.

I don't know. That is still lots of money, especially if you have credit card bills to pay.

As always, keep in mind that there are two reasons why people are poor:
- They do not earn enough money
- They spend too much money
People dwell too much on reason one and tend to ignore reason two.

This is the last thing you should be considering buying if you're currently suffering from a personal case of mortgage fraud meltdown.

Being Less Poor: iPhone Madness - 28 June 2007

h/t to Little Green Footballs where I saw news of the iPhone price reduction first.

More being less poor wisdom by clicking the label below.

Swedish Liberals Concealing the Crimes of Communism

I had first covered this story in May with my post "Swedish Government Concealing the Crimes of Communism". Well it seems that the Swedish Government has recently been planning to expose/educate Swedish children on the crimes of communism. Good for them. Funny thing is that some liberals are coming out against teaching the truth as that will result in the children being less likely to be liberals:
A recent opinion piece in Biblioteksbladet magazine (a periodical for Swedish librarians) denounced the government's plan to spread knowledge to students about the horrors of communism.

In the article, two school librarians write that informing students about the crimes of communism would be wrong as it would risk making the pupils' views more right-wing. - The Local, Sweden
Yes, the article centers are only two librarians. But they are just the tip of a huge iceberg of people who surely believe the same thing.

It is an interesting thought, that knowing the truth about communism will make a person less-likely to be a liberal. (Or at least, less liberal.) Since they don't like that result, their answer is to keep the truth away from people.

In some respects, you can't really blame them for their reaction as we are all victims of our own experiences. For them, they believed in the lie that was the Soviet Union. Forget that the whole dream has fallen like a house of cards, it is the right-wingers who are the real enemy. The problem is, their children will not be exposed to the myth that was the Soviet Union to help mold them into the good little socialists that their education system normally pumps out. So now, some believe that the crimes need to be concealed so that the children can make the same mistake as their parents.

This is telling too in that it seems that these two liberal librarians think that you have to be somewhat ignorant of facts to be a liberal and these are the very type of people who others go to get better informed. As librarians they are gate-keepers to information. Who knows how many people they steered away from the information that they were seeking simply because they did not believe that access to the information was complimentary to their beliefs. Thank God for the Internet for providing easy access to all sorts of information. (In most countries.)

As I mentioned before, this problem is much bigger than just Sweden. European Governments are stuffed with Socialists, Communists and sympathizers (With 200 members the PES's "Socialist Group" is the second largest group in the European Parliament. - Wikipedia) all conspiring against any full accounting of communism in Europe. Read my post "Europe's Lingering Scar of Communism" for more details on how Communism continues to be a political force in Europe including the European Union.

Remember:

Communism is an ideology that seeks to establish a classless, stateless social organization, based upon common ownership of the means of production. It can be classified as a branch of the broader socialist movement - Wikipedia - Communism

Communists are socialists. So how 'communist' is your socialist politician? (Or librarian for that matter)

More Here:
Swedish Government Concealing the Crimes of Communism - FFI - 11 May 2007
Europe's Lingering Scar of Communism - FFI - 23 Jan 2007

LINKS:
THE FACTS TOO EDUCATIONAL FOR SWEDES - The Astute Bloggers (I saw this story Here First)

Swedish Moonbats Suppress Knowledge of Communist Genocide - Moonbattery

Coast Guard Threatens Hawaii Superferry Protesters with Serious Fines and Jailtime

In my previous post "Econuts and Moonbats Stop Hawaii Superferry (For Now)", I gave the Coast Guard a hard time for their handling of the Hawaii Superferry protesters. I was not alone in this criticism. Of course, the Coast Guard got caught off-guard by assuming that the protesters would act in a civilized manner, which a small, but damaging minority, did not, preventing the vessel from docking.

Well they seem to have regrouped, and expecting that the protesters will ignore any court decision that permits the ferry to sail, have issued a warning of the severe penalties that protesters who break the law will face:

COAST GUARD READIES FOR HAWAII SUPERFERRY VOYAGE

HONOLULU - The Coast Guard here, in support of joint federal, state and county plans, is planning for the next voyage of the Hawaii Superferry to Kauai, on a still undetermined date, by assembling Coast Guard assets to enforce security zones in Nawiliwili Harbor.

Along with plans for the security zones, the Coast Guard Captain of the Port, working with other federal, state and local officials, is planning to designate a safe demonstration area during the Superferry's next Kauai voyage. This demonstration area, roughly between Kalapaki Beach and Kukii Point, will allow people who choose to demonstrate to do so safely, peacefully and legally, and will allow the Superferry and its passengers to safely use the port.

The fixed security zones will be established in Nawiliwili Harbor before and during the Superferry's arrival. Details on the security zones and the safe demonstration area will be distributed after the Superferry's next voyage to Kauai is announced.

Protestors who fail to comply with orders pertaining to the security zones, purposely injure or threaten to injure an enforcement officer or attempt to destruct or interfere with vessels may be punished by imprisonment for up to 10 years, and may be fined up to $25,000. Any vessel used to violate a security zone, including surfboards, kayaks and canoes, may be immediately confiscated and forfeited.

"The Coast Guard, local, state and other federal authorities share a common goal of ensuring the safety and security of our ports, the vessels that call, and all the people who use them," said Captain Vince Atkins, Commander of Coast Guard Sector Honolulu and Captain of the Port.

"We support the rights of citizens to conduct safe, peaceful and legal protests, and the Coast Guard is working with our partners throughout Hawaii to address security issues related to the Superferry's next voyage here," Atkins said.

Editor's Note: For Coast Guard information regarding safety and security plans for the next Hawaii Superferry voyage to Kauai, contact the project's public information office at 808-842-2029 or 808-842-2070. - US Coast Guard Press Release

Protesters have the right to protest. However, those traveling on the superferry also have rights which the protesters have seen fit to ignore. They got a free-pass last time but it seems that further violations will come at a cost to the protester, at least those who attempt to interfere with the movement of the ship.

Protest all you want. Just stay out of the way.


Update: 5 Sept
Here are some more details about why the Coast Guard did not act to clear the harbor the first time:

Why USCG's Nawiliwili protection failed - KAUAI 05 September – New details have emerged on why the US Coast Guard was unable to protect Hawaii Superferry's Alakai in Kauai's Nawiliwili Harbor last week.

According to information published in the Federal Register, the USCG faced limitations in its ability to enforce the security zone law during protests on 26-27 August. Because the entrance to the Nawiliwili Harbour is "difficult for large vessels in all but calm weather", the master chose not to enter the protestor-filled harbour; as a result, the protesters were not within the 91-metre radius of the ship's moving security zone. "This did not provide the USCG with the authority to clear the channel", which "substantially complicated an already difficult transit and created substantial risk of damage and injury", said the USCG in the Federal Register filing.

It was also noted that protesters threw rocks and bottles at USCG personnel from a jetty south of Nawiliwili Park.

To remedy the issue, a new stationary security zone will be in effect from 1 September-31 October that covers the waters of Nawiliwili Harbour as well as the jetty. This will provide the USCG increased authority to enforce security zone laws and better prevent protesters from impeding the ferry transit. Hawaii Superferry has yet to announce when it will resume calls to Kauai. - Fairplay Daily News (home Page)

That is a pretty interesting catch 22. The Coast Guard could not forcibly remove the protesters as the ship did not enter the harbor. The ship did not enter the harbor because the protesters were blocking the way. Hopefully the new rules will make everyone happy.